| 1 Louisville | 1 Louisville | 2009 Final Results | Pittsburgh 1 | Pittsburgh 1 | |||||
| 16 Morehead St | 1 Louisville | Pittsburgh 1 | E Tenn St 16 | ||||||
| 8 Ohio St | 9 Siena | Oklahoma St 8 | Oklahoma St 8 | ||||||
| 9 Siena | 1 Louisville | Pittsburgh 1 | Tennessee 9 | ||||||
| 5 Utah | 12 Arizona | Wisconsin 12 | Florida St 5 | ||||||
| 12 Arizona | 12 Arizona | Xavier 4 | Wisconsin 12 | ||||||
| 4 Wake Forest | 13 Cleveland St | Xavier 4 | Xavier 4 | ||||||
| 13 Cleveland St | Midwest | 2 Michigan St | Villanova 3 | East | Portland St 13 | ||||
| 6 W Virginia | 11 Dayton | UCLA 6 | UCLA 6 | ||||||
| 11 Dayton | 3 Kansas | Villanova 3 | VCU 11 | ||||||
| 3 Kansas | 3 Kansas | Villanova 3 | Villanova 3 | ||||||
| 14 N Dakota St | 2 Michigan St | Villanova 3 | American 14 | ||||||
| 7 Boston Coll | 10 USC | Texas 7 | Texas 7 | ||||||
| 10 USC | 2 Michigan St | Duke 2 | Minnesota 10 | ||||||
| 2 Michigan St | 2 Michigan St | Duke 2 | Duke 2 | ||||||
| 15 Rob Morris | 2 Michigan St | N Carolina 1 | Binghamton 15 | ||||||
| 1 N Carolina | |||||||||
| 1 Connecticut | 1 Connecticut | N Carolina 1 | N Carolina 1 | ||||||
| 16 Chattanooga | 1 Connecticut | Tie Breaker: 161 | N Carolina 1 | Radford 16 | |||||
| 8 BYU | 9 Texas AM | LSU 8 | LSU 8 | ||||||
| 9 Texas AM | 1 Connecticut | N Carolina 1 | Butler 9 | ||||||
| 5 Purdue | 5 Purdue | W Kentucky 12 | Illinois 5 | ||||||
| 12 N Iowa | 5 Purdue | Gonzaga 4 | W Kentucky 12 | ||||||
| 4 Washington | 4 Washington | Gonzaga 4 | Gonzaga 4 | ||||||
| 13 Miss St | West | 1 Connecticut | N Carolina 1 | South | Akron 13 | ||||
| 6 Marquette | 6 Marquette | Arizona St 6 | Arizona St 6 | ||||||
| 11 Utah St | 3 Missouri | Syracuse 3 | Temple 11 | ||||||
| 3 Missouri | 3 Missouri | Syracuse 3 | Syracuse 3 | ||||||
| 14 Cornell | 3 Missouri | Oklahoma 2 | SF Austin 14 | ||||||
| 7 California | 10 Maryland | Michigan 10 | Clemson 7 | ||||||
| 10 Maryland | 2 Memphis | Oklahoma 2 | Michigan 10 | ||||||
| 2 Memphis | 2 Memphis | Oklahoma 2 | Oklahoma 2 | ||||||
| 15 CSU-Nridge | Morgan St 15 | ||||||||